My Top 8 Supper Clubs (5 Minnesota and 3 in Wisconsin)

What is a supper club? It depends on who you ask and where you live. For many, a supper club is a restaurant typically located in the Midwest and Upper Midwest.  Supper clubs are known for their unique atmosphere, delicious food, relish trays, and extensive classic drink menu—bonus points if you add ice cream drinks to the list.

A cozy dinner table setup with a drink, candle, menu, salt, and pepper shakers. The menu reads "Creekside Supper Club & Lounge," a charming touch reminiscent of classic Minnesota supper clubs.

Supper clubs typically serve various American comfort food dishes, such as prime rib, New York strips, broiled fish, roasted chicken, and meatloaf. There is a strong list of potatoes, including au gratin, baked or mashed. They also often have a salad bar, and I am very happy if they serve French, blue cheese, and ranch dressing in a stainless steel tri-cup bowl that spins. 

Here are my top 8 super clubs as well as some of my classic supper club recipes

The 8 Best Upper Midwest Supper Clubs

A close-up of a hamburger with grilled onions and a golden brown bun on a wooden surface, reminiscent of the classic fare you might find at supper clubs in Wisconsin or Minnesota.

Wiederholt’s Supper Club – Hastings, MN

The food is very good, and it must be because we drive 40 miles to get there! I had a small filet, and it was perfect. Kurt had the Prime Rib Special, and it was thick-cut and marbled, just like he likes it. Very nice relish plate and yummy rolls and toast basket.

Phils Tara Hideaway  – Stillwater, MN

Greek food at a supper club? Yes, and it’s good. Phils is classic and easy to get to right off the highway. Classic steaks, broiled walleye, fish fry, and you get a choice of potato or a side of pasta which is a nice change of pace.

Fisher’s Club – Avon, MN

Fisher’s Club is a popular spot for locals and tourists alike, and it is known for its classic American cuisine and lakeside setting. The restaurant was famously co-owned by Garrison Keilor. The restaurant has a casual and relaxed atmosphere, and the staff is friendly and attentive. The menu features a variety of classic American dishes, such as their famous walleye,  ribs, and roasted chicken.  The food is consistently good, and the portions are generous.

Jensen’s Supper Club – Eagan, MN

The filets are generous 8-ounce portions and done just right. The Ceasar salad is fresh, crisp, and flavorful, and served with real parmesan. The fresh baked, steaming hot popovers are true comfort food, served with whipped honey butter and amazing. Also, don’t miss the coconut shrimp and the cosmopolitan because you know I am bringing back the 90s. The service is always friendly, professional, and efficient. 

Creekside Supper Club – Minneapolis, MN

This place was re-imagined to look like an old super club, and they really did it right down to the fountain in the lobby and the cigarette machine. Walleye, fish fry, prime rib, and an excellent short rib round out this menu with a nice selection of potatoes, including loaded baked hashbrowns or au gratin. Get the popovers and the smoked trout spread too.

Laurel Supper Club – New Richmond, WI

The Laurel has a good selection of traditional supper club cocktails, including a brandy old-fashioned. We were all served fresh from the oven popovers with honey butter and a water carafe. Three of us had variations of shrimp as our main entrees (served with salad, soup, and a choice of potato), and another had prime ribs.

Simpsons Super Club – Waupaca, WI

This has been a favorite spot for my family and other visitors to the Chain of Lakes for years. Broiled haddock, broiled fish, and prime rib are their specialties, along with the au graten potatoes.

Ishnala Supper Club, Lake Denton, WI

This supper club on Mirror Lake outside Wisconsin Dells is a classic. My parents were engaged here and celebrated their wedding anniversary here as well.  The restaurant got its start in 1953 and specialized in the Old Fashioned.  The menu features the usual steak, seafood, duck, ribs, fish, and lamb. Reservations are not accepted, and the restaurant is only open seasonally, typically from April through October. 

Supper Club Recipes

Looking for the supper club vibe at home? Pour yourself a drink and fire up the grill to make a nice steak. Then choose from my list of steakhouse sides for the perfect accompaniment to your meal.

1
A red casserole dish filled with mashed potatoes, topped with shredded cheese and chopped chives, on a wooden counter with a knife and scattered cheese and chives beside it.
Loaded Baked Potato Hot Dish
This potato dish is great at feeding a crowd and saves you the time of stuffing each potato shell
Check out this recipe
2
A white dish with roasted baby potatoes garnished with a sprig of rosemary on a wooden surface.
Roasted Potatoes
Roasted potatoes are the perfect side for a weeknight dinner or a holiday meal.
Check out this recipe
3
Double Potato Gratin with Apples and Onions
Who doesn't love a savory potato gratin? How about adding sweet potatoes, caramelized onions, and apples to amplify the sweetness?
Check out this recipe
4
A small glass jar filled with green pesto sauce is placed next to a sprig of basil and a purple chive flower on a wooden surface.
Green Goddess Dressing
Green Goddess Dressing is great on green salads, over pasta salad or as a dip for chips or crudite
Check out this recipe
5
A plate of Farmers Market wedge salad with iceberg lettuce, diced tomatoes, crispy bacon, blue cheese dressing, and chopped herbs.
Farmers Market Wedge Salad With Shepherd’s Way Blue Cheese Dressing
The local farmers market has everything you need for a beautiful farm-fresh wedge salad drizzled with the best blue cheese dressing.
Check out this recipe
6
A freshly mixed creamy ranch dressing with chopped herbs in a green ceramic bowl held by a hand, on a wooden surface.
Big Woods Blue best blue cheese dressing
The Big Woods Blue Cheese, made by Shepherds Way Farms, has been voted one of the country's best blue cheeses. Here it shines in a blue cheese dressing that is perfectly at home in a wedge salad.
Check out this recipe
7
A close-up view of a bowl filled with creamy white sauce with black specks, placed on a wooden surface.
Tarragon Buttermilk Ranch Dressing Recipe
Check out this recipe
8
Asparagus spears wrapped in prosciutto are arranged on a baking tray, seasoned with black pepper and grated cheese, ready for cooking—an ideal addition to your early summer recipes.
Asparagus wrapped prosciutto
These tasty spears are salty and roasty
Check out this recipe
9
Overhead view of a metal ladle filled with a thick creamy liquid, on a textured brown surface.
Caesar Dressing (No Raw Eggs!)
This dressing hack is from Heavy Table contributor John Garland, as published in the Heavy Table newsletter.
Check out this recipe
10
Carmelized Onion Cranberry Butter
This flavored butter is at home on a Parker House roll or slathered over sourdough and is perfect for the holiday table
Check out this recipe
11
A red, lidded pot on a wooden surface, filled with a dish topped with crushed crackers or breadcrumbs. The lid is placed to the right of the pot.
Creamed Corn
This creamed corn recipe is a riff on my grandma's recipe. I start by cooking grated onion and then making a roux, and then add frozen or canned corn. Pour into a casserole dish and top with bread crumbs or crushed Saltine crackers and you have the perfect side dish for the holidays.
Check out this recipe
12
Cheesy Creamed Corn Pudding Hot Dish
This creamed corn is a perfect side for a Ribeye Steak, Pork Chop, or Roast Chicken or on a potluck buffet for the holidays
Check out this recipe
13
A white baking dish filled with creamy spinach next to a can of panko bread crumbs, a small bowl of shredded cheese, a goat cheese log, and a pepper grinder on a wooden countertop.
Creamed Spinach With a Crunchy Crumb Topping
This creamed spinach is a perfect side dish to serve alongside your favorite roast chicken recipe or butter-basted inch-and-a-half perfectly marbled rib eye straight from your butcher. Adding garlic herb goat cheese amps up the flavor making this dish buttery and savory with the crispiness of the crunchy bread crumbs.
Check out this recipe
14
A wooden bowl filled with peeled white pearl onions, viewed from above.
Creamed Pearl Onions
These creamed onions are delicious with Turkey for Thanksgiving
Check out this recipe
15
Two roasted squash halves stuffed with a mixture of wild rice, vegetables, and herbs are served on a white plate. Two forks rest next to the plate on a wooden surface.
Wild Rice Stuffed Acorn Squash
This acorn squash stuffed with Wild Rice is inspired by my visit with the Sioux Chef Sean Sherman and is made with ingredients indigenous to North America. Check out his amazing cookbook, "The Sioux Chef's Indigenous Kitchen."
Check out this recipe
16
A serving dish filled with creamy instant pot risotto, topped with green peas and garnished with fresh microgreens. A silver utensil is placed inside the dish.
Instant Pot Risotto (5-Minute Recipe)
Check out this recipe
17
A black dish filled with baked cauliflower au gratin, topped with a golden brown crust, on a wooden table. A wooden spoon is resting in the dish.
Cauliflower and Goat Cheese Gratin
This side dish is perfect for a roast chicken with Thyme or a poached steak in a cast iron skillet for a "steakhouse" side. Served alongside the perfect butter basted Rib Eye steak from your favorite butcher with marbled fat throughout cut an inch and a half high – you have yourself a perfect steak house side dish worthy of any 5-star restaurant
Check out this recipe
18
A baked Swiss chard gratin with a golden-brown crumb topping and visible green vegetables in a brown ceramic dish.
Swiss Chard Gratin Recipe
Make this Swiss chard gratin with a cheesy breadcrumb topping in about 30 minutes for an elevated side dish all year round!
Check out this recipe
19
Four jars of sliced cucumbers with herbs are stored upside down in a refrigerator, likely being pickled.
Refrigerator Pickles
Of all the things I hear people complain about when discussing pickle recipes, what seems to stand out is how to keep them crunchy. Try this technique that cools the jars upside down before placing them right side up in the refrigerator.
Check out this recipe
20
A white rectangular plate with stuffed mushrooms, garnished with a mixture of minced ingredients, displayed in a row.
Baked Stuffed Mushrooms
These mushrooms stuffed with sausage, cream cheese and kale are lovely; one bite appetizers
Check out this recipe
Home » My Top 8 Supper Clubs (5 Minnesota and 3 in Wisconsin)
Scroll to Top